India is Growing. But where are Good Jobs?
India’s economy is growing, corporate profits are strong and the country remains one of the world’s youngest large economies. Yet ask a young graduate about the job market and the picture often sounds very different. The problem is not simply unemployment. It is the shortage of stable, productive and reasonably paid jobs.
This contradiction deserves attention. In FY2023-24, corporate profits rose sharply, while employment growth among companies was far more modest. Technology, automation, outsourcing and productivity improvements increasingly allow businesses to expand without adding employees at the same pace.
That is good for efficiency, but it creates a difficult question for a young country: if economic growth does not generate enough jobs and higher wages, how does prosperity reach ordinary households?
India’s headline unemployment numbers only partly answer that question. A person doing occasional farm work, helping in a family enterprise, driving for a platform or running a tiny business may be classified as employed. But being employed is not the same as having a secure livelihood.
This is why India’s bigger challenge is arguably underemployment and job quality, rather than unemployment alone.
The pressure is most visible among the young and educated. India’s median age is around 30, and roughly two-thirds of the population is of working age. That should be an enormous economic advantage. But a demographic dividend is not automatic. Millions of young people entering the workforce each year need opportunities that match their education and aspirations.
Here lies another mismatch. India is producing more graduates, but employers increasingly need specific capabilities rather than degrees alone. Data analytics, AI, advanced manufacturing, industrial maintenance, cybersecurity, sales and communication skills are becoming more valuable. Too many students still leave college with credentials but limited exposure to real workplaces.
At the same time, India may need to rethink what constitutes a “good job”. For decades, middle-class families have preferred office employment over technical and vocational careers. Yet skilled electricians, machine operators, automobile technicians, welders and specialised construction workers can increasingly earn as much as, and sometimes more than, graduates entering oversupplied administrative roles.
The larger structural problem is the nature of India’s growth. Successful sectors such as IT, finance, telecommunications and technology can generate enormous value without employing millions of people. India has built impressive capabilities in these industries, but has not created labour-intensive manufacturing jobs on the scale achieved by countries such as China and Vietnam.
That makes manufacturing critical. Textiles, food processing, footwear, electronics assembly, furniture, automobiles and light engineering can provide the missing bridge between low-productivity agricultural work and highly skilled professional employment.
Women represent another major opportunity. India cannot fully benefit from its demographic advantage while a large proportion of working-age women remain outside formal employment. Better transport, safer workplaces, childcare and flexible employment could add not only workers, but also millions of additional income-earning households.
There is an equally important question about wages. Corporate profitability is desirable. Profitable businesses invest, innovate and pay taxes. But when profits and productivity consistently rise faster than wages and employment, the benefits of growth become increasingly concentrated.
This matters even to businesses. Employees are also consumers. If household incomes do not rise sufficiently, consumption eventually suffers. Sustainable economic growth therefore requires a healthier relationship between productivity, profits, employment and wages.
Artificial intelligence makes the issue more urgent. Some of the entry-level jobs that once absorbed graduates in IT services, customer support, finance and back-office operations are becoming easier to automate. Producing ever more graduates for the same traditional office jobs will not solve the problem.
India consequently needs a different employment strategy: more labour-intensive manufacturing, stronger MSMEs, far more apprenticeships, better vocational education and closer collaboration between industry and educational institutions. The goal should not simply be to create jobs, but to create productive jobs that allow incomes to rise with skills and experience.
We may also need to change how we judge economic success. GDP growth, corporate profits, stock-market records and investment announcements matter. But so do real wages, graduate unemployment, female workforce participation, manufacturing employment and the number of workers moving from informal work into secure employment.
India possesses something most ageing economies would envy: hundreds of millions of young people who want to work, consume, learn and improve their lives.
That can become India's greatest economic advantage. But only if growth creates opportunity broadly enough.
The real measure of India’s economic success will not be how profitable its largest companies become. It will be whether a 25-year-old entering the workforce can find a productive job, earn a decent living and reasonably expect to do better ten years later.
If India gets that equation right, its young population will truly become a demographic dividend. If it does not, the country risks an uncomfortable paradox: an economy that becomes richer while too many of its young people continue waiting for prosperity to reach them.
Get membership to feature your article.





Comments